Elias Rabinovitch Law
Civil Law November 4, 2026 6 min read

Hurt in a Car Accident While Working: Claim WSIB or Sue?

This page is legal information, not legal advice. It describes the law in general terms and cannot account for the facts of your situation. Reading it does not create a lawyer and client relationship, and neither does speaking with or contacting Elias Rabinovitch Law. For advice you can act on, speak with a lawyer about your own matter.

Traffic on Highway 401 in Toronto - car accidents while driving for work and the WSIB election

If you were hurt in a crash while driving for work, you may have two routes to compensation and the law will make you pick one. The deadline to pick is three months.

Most workplace injuries in Ontario run only through the WSIB. A car accident on the job is different, because the person who caused it is often a stranger to your workplace. That opens the possibility of a lawsuit, and the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act then requires an election that has real consequences either way.

First question: can you sue at all?

Section 28 takes away the right to sue for many workplace injuries. A worker of a Schedule 1 employer cannot sue any Schedule 1 employer, or a director, executive officer or worker of one, over the injury. So if the other driver was the employee of a Schedule 1 employer and was driving in the course of their own employment, the lawsuit is generally barred and WSIB is your route.

If the other driver was a member of the public on personal business, section 28 does not protect them, and you may have both a WSIB claim and a right to sue. There are finer points, including an exception in section 28(4) where a vehicle or equipment was rented out without an operator, and these cases often turn on details of who owned what and who was working for whom.

Where the answer is unclear, section 31 lets a party to the lawsuit, or an auto insurer from whom accident benefits are claimed, ask the Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal to decide whether the right to sue has been taken away. WSIAT's jurisdiction on that question is exclusive, and its decision is final; it cannot be reviewed in court.

The section 30 election

If you can sue, section 30 requires you to elect between claiming WSIB benefits and bringing the lawsuit, and to notify the Board. The election must be made within three months of the accident. The Board can allow more time where it considers it just, but that is discretionary.

The default matters. If you make no election, section 30(6) deems you, absent evidence to the contrary, to have elected not to receive WSIB benefits. Doing nothing is a choice, and usually not the one people would make if they understood it.

If you choose WSIB benefits

You receive benefits through the insurance plan, and the WSIB steps into your shoes for the lawsuit. Under section 30(10), the Board is subrogated to your right of action and decides whether to sue, whether to settle, and on what terms. If it recovers more than it spent on the action and on your benefits, section 30(12) requires it to pay you the surplus, which then reduces your future benefits.

If you choose to sue

You run the lawsuit yourself, and you are not necessarily giving up WSIB entirely. Under section 30(14), if the judgment you obtain is less than what your WSIB benefits would have cost, you can claim benefits for the shortfall. A settlement works the same way only if the Board approved it before it was made. Settling without that approval can cost you the top-up.

A lawsuit has its own timeline. Most Ontario claims must be started within two years, and car accident claims carry rules on thresholds and deductibles that affect what can be recovered for pain and suffering. Those are reasons to get advice on the lawsuit side before electing, not after.

How to think about the choice

  • Certainty against upside. WSIB benefits do not depend on proving fault. A lawsuit can recover heads of damages WSIB does not pay, but only if fault is established and the defendant is insured or able to pay.
  • Control. Electing benefits hands control of the lawsuit to the Board. Electing to sue keeps it with you.
  • Timing. Three months comes quickly when you are injured. Treatment, time off work and insurance forms all compete for attention, which is how people end up making the election by default.

For more on WSIB deadlines and appeals, see the WSIB claims and appeals page and how WSIB objections and appeals work.

Common questions

Can I sue after a car accident at work in Ontario?

Only if the person at fault is not protected by section 28 of the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act. You generally cannot sue a Schedule 1 employer or its workers acting in the course of employment, but you may be able to sue a member of the public.

How long do I have to choose between WSIB and a lawsuit?

Three months from the accident under section 30(4), with notice to the Board. The Board can extend the period where it considers it just. If you make no election, you are deemed, absent evidence to the contrary, to have elected not to receive WSIB benefits.

What happens to the lawsuit if I choose WSIB benefits?

The WSIB is subrogated to your right of action under section 30(10) and decides whether to sue or settle. If it recovers more than it spent on the action and your benefits, it pays you the surplus, which reduces future benefits.

If I sue and recover less than WSIB would have paid, can I still get benefits?

Yes, for the shortfall under section 30(14) where a judgment is less than the cost of the benefits. A settlement qualifies only if the Board approved it before it was made.

WSIB Car Accident Section 30 Election Right to Sue WSIAT Injured Workers

Suing, being sued, or in a dispute in Ontario?

A free, confidential consultation will tell you what the process looks like, what it is likely to cost, and whether it is worth running.

Prefer to read first? Civil litigation practice · Case results · How fees work

Elias Rabinovitch, Toronto criminal defence lawyer
About the Lawyer

Elias Rabinovitch

Elias Rabinovitch is a Toronto criminal defence lawyer and the founder of Elias Rabinovitch Law. A graduate of Osgoode Hall Law School, he handles every file personally and practises across Toronto and the Greater Toronto Area. Urgent calls reach him rather than an intake line. Read his full profile.

Request Free Evaluation